Matthews' disallowed goal is causing outrage and highlighting the inconsistency among NHL officials
Parity in officiating has been around probably as long as there has been officiating. There are a couple of reasons for this for sure, including, but not limited to, each individual having a different opinion (yes this includes referees, they're people too), and simple human error.
On Wednesday night, Toronto Maple Leafs forward
Auston Matthews and his teammates thought that he had tied a longstanding NHL record, scoring in 11 consecutive road games - a record that was set back in 1988-89 by Steve Yzerman, and tied in 1993-94 by Pavel Bure. The problem was the the puck that found its way into the net did so off of Matthews' skate blade.
The call on the ice was that of a good goal, but after a very quick review and not much deliberation at all, the goal was overturned, costing Matthews a share of the obscure road-goal scoring record. The problem is, there have been pucks that have gone in off of very similar redirections, with the goals being allowed. Here's a good example below.
So if one of these goals was allowed, why wasn't the other? They're, at large, the same play. Pucks being redirected towards the net with the skate blade, with the only difference being that Tierney didn't even attempt to swipe at the puck with his stick after the redirection, whereas Auston Matthews clearly tried to play the puck with his stick afterward.
This is just another example of how the officials, one way or another, got it wrong. Either BOTH of these plays are good goals, or NEITHER of these plays are good goals. The NHL has to stop with this double-standard nonsense. I get that there are nuances to consider with every individual play, but in my opinion, if the call on the ice is a good goal, there was simply not enough there to overturn it, given what we've seen with other, more egregious kicking motions having been allowed.
Previously on MapleLeafsDaily
|
3 hours ago | By Dean Chaudhry William Nylander Reaffirms What His Primary Goal is Heading into the 2025-26 Season |
|
7 hours ago | By Dean Chaudhry Maple Leafs Defenseman Admits to Being Misidentified as Toronto Blue Jays Pitcher |
|
10 hours ago | By Dean Chaudhry Toronto Native May Now Finally Be Available and He's a Natural Fit for the Maple Leafs |
|
13 hours ago | By Ryan Smitheram 'It's Never His Fault': Analyst Cooks Mitch Marner For Blaming Fans For His Departure from Maple Leafs |
|
14 hours ago | By Ryan Smitheram Mitch Marner Reveals Which Leafs Teammate Was the Toughest to Inform of His Decision to Leave |
|
15 hours ago | By TJ Tucker Ex-Maple Leafs Draft Pick and Marlies Defenceman Slapped With Contract Termination |
|
17 hours ago | By Dean Chaudhry New Video Shows Mitch Marner Visibly Shaken by Behaviour of Maple Leafs Fans |
|
Aug 28 | By Lukas Peters Leafs Miss Out as Former Brad Treliving Draft Pick Signs PTO With Eastern Conference Rival |