Toronto Hockey Daily has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Maple Leafs, NHL or NHLPA

TORONTO HOCKEY DAILY


Former Leafs GM calls out current leadership group, brings up interesting captaincy discussion


PUBLICATION
Dean Chaudhry
December 1, 2025  (9:26)
SHARE THIS STORY
FOLLOW US

Toronto Maple Leafs forwards Matthew Knies, Auston Matthews, and John Tavares celebrate a goal scored against the Ottawa Senators.
Photo credit: Dan Hamilton - Imagn Images

Former Leafs GM Gord Stellick calls out the current leadership group and believes the team made the wrong decision in naming Auston Matthews the captain.

For the Toronto Maple Leafs, one key aspect missing from their team this year is leadership. With the team stuck in the weeds and looking completely lost on a nightly basis, they need their veterans to step up, but more importantly, their captain.
Many questioned whether or not Auston Matthews should have been named the team's captain after John Tavares wore the C for his 2nd through 6th years in Toronto. However, after signing 4-year extension worth $13.25M per season, the Leafs transitioned to Matthews, and to his credit, Tavares was all class about it.
With the Leafs now playing some of their least inspired hockey in a decade, is it time to revisit that decision? Former Leafs GM Gord Stellick believes so, claiming that your best player doesn't always have to be your leader, and that things have changed since the transition.
There's nothing wrong if your best player isn't a leader. All I can say is last year, you couldn't be more of a team guy, a classy guy, the way he (John Tavares) handled the transition, and then the leadership meant nothing, it's not even a visible thing. It's almost like an award to wear the C.
Where Stellick might have bit off more than he can chew is when he said he felt that Morgan Rielly should have been named captain instead. Given that Tavares' contract situation was a bit cloudy at the time, it made sense why they made the change, but looking back at it now, it was definitely a mistake.
If you would have asked me a few years ago, I would've picked Morgan Rielly. He kind of strikes me as a captain, but its an important thing being the captain, and the leadership group is important.

Tavares is in a class of his own when it comes to leading by example, and Rielly, like Matthews, hasn't shown he can be the alpha of the team, despite being the longest tenured Maple Leaf.
However, what's done is done, and the onus is now on the current leadership group, which is anchored by Matthews.
At some point you got to evolve to be the real leaders, and that's where we're going to find out now, a litmus test, about a team that has no business [being] where they are right now, and can this leadership group lead them?

Tavares is still a major piece of the puzzle and his play on the ice this year has risen to new heights. He can't do this alone and will need the help of his captain and fellow alternates and assistants to pick up the slack and get this team on track before the wheels completely fall off.
In other words, Tavares might have to act as the de facto captain. but without the C stitched on his chest.
POLL
2 HOURS AGO   |   118 ANSWERS
Former Leafs GM calls out current leadership group, brings up interesting captaincy discussion

Who should be the Maple Leafs' captain?


TORONTO HOCKEY DAILY
COPYRIGHT @2025 • ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE  ·  PRIVACY POLICY  ·  COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED  ·  SITEMAP  ·  ROBOTS.TXT