Berube's Head-Scratching Decisions Put Nylander and Robertson in the Spotlight

Even after starting the season on an absolute tear, it seems Craig Berube isn't fully satisfied with William Nylander's play when on the top line.

Despite recording 8 goals and 23 points in 13 games, Berube made the surprising decision to move Nylander off the top line following an impressive performance against the Carolina Hurricanes.

Nylander has arguably been Toronto's best forward this season. He's been extremely dynamic, creative, and a nearly impossible to stop in the offensive zone.

His ability to generate scoring chances and finish under pressure has made him one of the NHL's most dangerous players early on. For that reason, the decision to move him to the second line has left many fans scratching their heads.

While it's not necessarily a punishment, Berube's adjustment may be strategic. The Leafs have relied heavily on their top line for offense, and creating a more balanced attack could pay off long-term.

By spreading out the firepower, Berube might be looking to strengthen Toronto's secondary scoring, an issue that's plagued the team in recent years.

In Nylander's place, Nick Robertson has once again been promoted to the top line. The skilled winger has quietly been one of Toronto's most consistent contributors this season, recording 4 goals and 9 points through 15 games.

On pace for a potential 22-goal, 49-point campaign, Robertson's mix of speed and tenacity could bring a new element alongside Auston Matthews and company.

Still, Berube's constant line shuffling is becoming a recurring storyline. While fresh combinations can spark production, the lack of sustained chemistry may ultimately hurt the team's ability to find consistency. T

The Leafs need stability just as much as they need creativity, and the balance between the two may determine how far this lineup can go.