With Huberdeau signing his new deal, of course Mitch Marner is trending; but do the two deals even compare?
As is expected anytime someone signs a new contract, a Maple Leaf is once again trending. Jonathan Huberdeau inked a deal with the Flames last night that will keep him in Calgary for the next 9 seasons (the last year of his current deal at $5.9M and 8 years on his new deal at $10.5M per season), so naturally, Mitch Marner's name had to be mentioned.
The fact of the matter is that, yes, when Marner signed his deal back in September of 2019, it was likely a slight overpay at the time. However, since then, the Markham, ON native has lived up to his end of the deal and then some. The only thing left for Marner now is some playoff success - something Huberdeau didn't experience until he was 28 years old on the fringe of turning 29. Yet for some reason, there is a large number of fans who believe that Huberdeau, who has already reached his ceiling, is better than Mitch Marner, who has yet to reach his.
As for Huberdeau, his overpay will begin pretty soon after his new deal kicks in. The first couple years of the deal, the Flames will certainly get their money's worth. Once he hits 32-33 years old, however.. that might be a different story. In terms of how they stack up at the moment, Marner himself projects to account for 3.6 wins for the Leafs this season. Huberdeau projects to account for just 2.5 wins for the Flames, per Top Down Hockey and JFresh Hockey.
As for who is the better player, that comes down to the criteria you're using to compare them. If we're comparing them on a purely offensive basis, Huberdeau's best season is superior to Marner's best season - so even the most die hard of Leafs fans might have to make that concession. But when you factor in their defensive impacts, Marner is vastly superior.
In my personal opinion, the comparisons are a reach. Marner is a full 4 years younger than Huberdeau. He's played just 6 seasons in the NHL to Huberdeau's 10. Marner relies on his speed, shiftiness and stickhandling, whereas Huberdeau is much stronger on the puck and relies on his strength to create space. Huberdeau also possesses a much better shot. They're different types of players. Yes, they're both playmakers, but Huberdeau is a pure offensive talent, while Marner is a 200-foot player with strong defensive instincts. It's like comparing apples to oranges. They're both fruit, but other than that..
The unrest that all of this is causing between Leafs fans and Flames fans (and I'm sure fans from other rival fanbases) over $400K is actually pretty overblown, if you ask me. They're both elite wingers for different reasons and comparing them would be doing a disservice to both of them. After all, they do rank 7th and 8th as the league's highest players. We know that Marner will continue to get better, we know that Huberdeau will eventually run out of steam as he gets older, so you can likely tilt the argument in Marner's favour there, but I'm sure neither team is losing sleep over which elite winger is more elite.
Previously on MapleLeafsDaily
POLL |
AOUT 5 | 418 ANSWERS With Huberdeau signing his new deal, of course Mitch Marner is trending; but do the two deals even compare? Who do you think is signed to the better deal? |
Mitch Marner | 160 | 38.3 % |
Jonathan Huberdeau | 89 | 21.3 % |
Both are good deals | 92 | 22 % |
Neither are good deals | 77 | 18.4 % |
List of polls |
|
3 hours ago | By Mike Armenti Starting Goalies Officially Named for 4 Nations Face-Off Opener Between Canada and Sweden |
|
4 hours ago | By TJ Tucker Top Maple Leafs Trade Target Suggests That He May Indeed Be Available |
|
5 hours ago | By Nick Matthews Auston Matthews Aims to Play Physical Against Leafs Teammates at 4 Nations Face-Off |
|
6 hours ago | By Dean Chaudhry Maple Leafs Now Have a Massive Advantage Over the Rest of the NHL |
|
19 hours ago | By Nick Matthews 25-Year-Old Defenseman in Utah May Be Perfect Trade Target for Maple Leafs |
|
21 hours ago | By Ryan Smitheram Leafs Have Significant Obstacle to Overcome to Move Any Significant Salary Out Ahead of Trade Deadline |
|
23 hours ago | By Dean Chaudhry Insider Urges the Toronto Maple Leafs to Avoid Dealing for Flyers Forward |
|
Feb 11 | By Mike Armenti William Nylander Draws Top Line Assignment for Sweden, Slotting In Next to Two Dynamic Forwards |